Petefish played multiple years on the men’s basketball and baseball teams at IC. He was the first player in IC history to have both 1,000 points and 300 assists. He was awarded Newcomer of the Year during his first year. In his senior season, he led the team in scoring, assists, and steals and was voted the team MVP. He received Second Team All-Conference honors. Petefish has cemented his name in the IC record books throughout his career. He ranks fifth in the baseball career record books for fewest runs allowed with 47. In basketball, he stands second in career steals with 181 and second in steals per game with 1.95. He is ninth in assists with 328 and ninth in assists per game with 3.53. Petefish is on the 1,000 point scorer list totaling 1105 points in his career as a Blueboy.